State Mandates As Political Cover

Today we’ll head straight to reader responses to Tuesday’s newsletter because they were so good and so important to ed reform writ large. This is exactly the kind of conversation I was hoping SCHOOLED would spur.

After praising phone bans, I asked:

Are phones so terrible that, like cigarettes, they should be treated as contraband in our schools? And prohibited at the state level? Is that also how you would treat, say, balanced literacy and three-queuing? What is the defining principle we should embrace so that we don’t try to micromanage everything from the state level but also encourage (or even require) schools to adopt evidence-based practices?

And boy did you have opinions!

Most tellingly, several respondents hit on the same theme: that local leaders often need the political cover of state mandates (or bans) in order to do the right thing.

Read the full post here.

Recent News

In her latest Forbes piece, Talia Milgrom‑Elcott exposes how unpaid student-teaching, mounting debt, and insufficient support are pushing aspiring educators — and their students — to the breaking point, and why reforming the system matters for us all.
Big news: Maya Morales Garcia and Talia Milgrom-Elcott named finalists for the Schwab Foundation’s 2026 Social Innovation Awards
Amid massive federal budget cuts, a small but mighty program honoring the nation’s best STEM teachers has been put on pause. In her latest article Talia Milgrom-Elcott asks: what does it say about our priorities when we cut science teachers — already as rare as unicorns — from the spotlight they deserve?